A warm welcome to all friends visiting the site with a loving invitation to read my personal expressions on movies, music, poetry and life.

Music and Movies are like Ears and Eyes to me and if you also feel the same, then you are going to enjoy every moment spent on my works here, for sure.

Do send in your valuable comments and suggestions as they would be my guide for all the future works.


  Directors I Love  
  Alfred Hitchcock  
  Mehboob Khan  
  Woody Allen  
  Akira Kurosawa  
  Basu Chatterjee  
  Bimal Roy  
  Charlie Chaplin  
  Chetan Anand  
  Govind Nihalani  
  Guru Dutt  
  Hrishikesh Mukherjee  
  Kamal Hassan  
  Ketan Mehta  
  Mrinal Sen  
  Quentin Tarantino  
  Raj Kapoor  
  Richard Attenborough  
  Sai Pranjpe  
  Satyajit Ray  
  Shyam Benegal  
  Steven Spielberg  
  Vijay Anand  
  Ram Gopal Verma  
  Ashutosh Gowariker  
  Mani Ratnam  
  Aleksandr Petrov  
  Saeed Akhtar Mirza  
  Shekhar Kapoor  
  Yash Chopra  
  Frank Capra  
  V. Shantaram  
  Billy Wilder  
  Rajkumar Hirani  
  Vishal Bhardwaj  
  Tigmanshu Dhulia  
  Dibaker Banerjee  
  Rajkumar Santoshi  
  Majid Majidi  
  Ritwik Ghatak  
  Clint Eastwood  
  Prakash Mehra  
  Manmohan Desai  
  Shoaib Mansoor  
  Anurag Kashyap  
  S. S. Rajamouli  
  B. R. Chopra  
  Stanley Kubrick  
  Also Active at  
  Gurmat Darshan.com  
  At Youtube.com  
  At Wordpress.com  
  At Facebook  
  At Twitter  
 April 2016 (17)
 March 2016 (10)
 February 2016 (10)
 January 2016 (9)
 December 2015 (11)
 November 2015 (10)
 October 2015 (10)
 September 2015 (11)
 August 2015 (12)
 July 2015 (15)
 June 2015 (10)
 May 2015 (15)
 April 2015 (16)
 March 2015 (12)
 February 2015 (10)
 January 2015 (14)
 December 2014 (11)
 November 2014 (10)
 October 2014 (10)
 September 2014 (12)
 August 2014 (12)
 July 2014 (21)
 June 2014 (23)
 May 2014 (24)
 April 2014 (23)
 March 2014 (21)
 February 2014 (26)
 January 2014 (28)
 December 2013 (10)
 November 2013 (14)
 October 2013 (16)
 September 2013 (14)
 August 2013 (14)
 July 2013 (12)
 June 2013 (11)
 May 2013 (23)
 April 2013 (10)
 March 2013 (14)
 February 2013 (14)
 January 2013 (15)
 December 2012 (18)
 November 2012 (14)
 October 2012 (15)
 September 2012 (14)
 August 2012 (15)
 July 2012 (12)
 June 2012 (14)
 May 2012 (16)
 April 2012 (15)
 March 2012 (10)
 February 2012 (11)
 January 2012 (11)
 December 2011 (10)
 November 2011 (11)
 October 2011 (15)
 September 2011 (10)
 August 2011 (11)
 July 2011 (11)
 June 2011 (13)
 May 2011 (16)
 April 2011 (14)
 March 2011 (11)
 February 2011 (10)
 January 2011 (12)
 December 2010 (10)
 November 2010 (12)
 October 2010 (11)
 September 2010 (11)
 August 2010 (12)
 July 2010 (12)
 June 2010 (11)
 May 2010 (14)
 April 2010 (15)
 March 2010 (14)
 February 2010 (12)
 January 2010 (15)
 December 2009 (12)
 November 2009 (14)
 October 2009 (15)
 September 2009 (18)
 August 2009 (14)
 July 2009 (16)
 June 2009 (18)
 May 2009 (16)
 April 2009 (18)
 March 2009 (20)
 February 2009 (19)
 January 2009 (20)
 December 2008 (20)
 November 2008 (17)
 October 2008 (21)
 September 2008 (19)
 August 2008 (22)
 July 2008 (23)
 June 2008 (21)
 May 2008 (25)
 April 2008 (22)
 March 2008 (25)
 February 2008 (22)
 January 2008 (22)
 December 2007 (24)
 November 2007 (22)
 October 2007 (22)
May 02, 2016 Monday     
We have often seen exceptional actors (unwillingly) getting caught in a ‘specific image format’ in Hindi films. The same is being repeated in Punjabi Cinema at present with Diljit Dosanjh, who is probably the most talented ‘singer turned actor’ of the current times if considered in comparative terms. A gifted performer, who finds himself trapped in the web of ‘mostly comic characters’ given to him as per the audience demand, a pattern that could only be broken once in the past and that too riding on the shoulders of an ever-controversial subject of 1984, touching right there where it hurts.
To be straight, it can either be 84, a social issue based film or a religious subject where the audience wouldn’t mind watching Diljit minus his quick, witty one-liners or naughty smiles. But otherwise a big majority of viewers are just there to enjoy yet another comical act from the man, who has really mastered the art in a short span of time of just 5 years (since JATT & JULIET). Personally I hope with the upcoming UDTA PUNJAB, he somehow manages to come out of this hit-monotonous trap for his own growth, but talking about his latest AMBARSARIYA, Diljit is once again doing the same kind of role, with the similar hilarious dialogues delivered with an impeccable comic timing, offering nothing new or fresh in terms of his individual performance.
Giving you a clear idea, AMBARSARIYA is lot better than (the cursed) MUKHTIAR CHADDHA but a lot less than the fresh & well-crafted SARDAR JI, heavily relying on the tried and tested formula the actor is known for.
So in case you are just interested in some timely entertaining scenes, a few good laughs here and there, a couple of catchy songs, three gorgeous female faces and Diljit in almost every frame of the film enacting a casually written screenplay with an absurdly executed climax you really don’t mind or damn care about, then AMBARSARIYA is just for you and it wouldn’t disappoint as a whole in return of your precious time and money spent in the multiplexes.
However, if you are among those true fans of the actor, who want him to grow, who want him to emerge as a path-breaking flag bearer of Punjabi cinema breaking this set pattern of comedy played like a funny clown, taking extra care about the subject, the writing and the execution of his carefully chosen projects, then AMBARSARIYA would be nothing more than an average-ordinary film, purposefully made to encash the current craze around the name without any polished, skillful direction, based on a script taking its inspirations from more than one sources.
Giving the film its deserving due, it progresses well with a worth praising cinematography and background score enhancing the opening sequences. The ‘official assassin’ twist successfully surprises the viewers without wasting much time and then the investigation of three Manpreet’s keeps them all engaged like a light comic entertainer having some thrilling elements. But sadly it’s the second half that yet again goes back to the same old routine formulas focusing on some unimpressive romantic moments, leading to a badly written and conceived climax that simply ruins the whole impact made by its entertaining first half.
The climax has a sequence of a stage show involving a 10 years old kid holding a real loaded gun, ready to press the trigger. And our hero instead of running and snatching it from his hands, goes on provoking him to fire with some spirited historical references as if the boy is well trained in fire-arms and has done it several times before shooting the people without killing them hitting at the safe spots. Here it seems the scene was specifically written to infuse some cliched patriotism mentioning few historical names, but I honestly couldn’t feel the same, stunned by such amateurish irresponsible implementation on screen involving ‘the star’ himself.
Unlike his earlier films, AMBARSARIYA has Diljit doing everything from 1 to 10 with no great support coming from the rest of the cast, particularly the three girls who sincerely keep trying to act and catch his unmatchable comic timing putting in all they have got. In other words, the film can easily be termed as a lame venture saved by ‘the one man army’ alone that neither has that polished visual appeal nor some competitive writing by the team, utilizing a highly capable subject revolving around an undercover agent. In fact throughout it’s more than two hours of duration AMBARSARIYA literally remains a childish ‘wannabe’ thriller that cannot afford to leave its parallel path of comedy deeply associated with its lead star.
Here would like to mention another serious contradiction I felt while watching a particular scene in the film where a family is eating cakes like some mad, eccentric people and an elderly Sikh person is also there sitting at the back portrayed as a silent-funny character in repeated shots. Now it’s really strange that the Punjabi community really feels offended and insulted, when a similar scene is found in a mainstream Hindi film featuring a big star, but nobody feels the same kind of shame or disgust laughing at such ridiculous comical scenes included in their own Punjabi films for exactly the same purpose. Certainly a point that first needs to be accepted and then deeply contemplated upon, before raising objections and strongly opposing to how others portray Sikh characters on screen in an unacceptable comic manner.
Anyway, coming back to the critique, let me share my own vision, how this project must have been conceived in its initial stages keeping in mind an unusual central character inspired from a successful and well appreciated Hindi film featuring Vidya Balan.
Yes, the film is KAHAANI and you must be remembering the most famous supporting character in it known as BOB BISWAS so subtly played by Saswata Chatterjee, who became so popular post the film that people started calling him Bob instead of his original name.
Now writers often get influenced by a particular famous character of a film or a novel and can intelligently weave a complete script around the same if given a free hand. AMBARSARIYA seems to be a perfect example of the same as its character of Diljit is almost exactly similar to Bob Biswas with a pinch of legitimacy added to it being the lead hero. So here too we have an ‘Insurance Agent’ with a given responsibility to complete his policy targets in the office, who in reality is a secret Raw agent silently eliminating (killing) the terrorists in their hideouts as per the tips given. Just like Bob, he also visits their homes ringing the door bells and then smilingly greets them all with a gun, completing his assigned deadly task like a thorough professional. The only difference being, that here he is not a criminal but an official assassin appointed by Raw (being the Hero of course!)
So writing a whole script around this fascinating character alone (taking some foreign inspirations for the ‘non-disclosure’ of name in the end) we have AMBARSARIYA focusing on a Chief Minister assassination targeted by a terrorist, who is one of the three key suspects (with identical names) being investigated by the Raw agent. Since the film keeps revolving around this secret agent alone right from its first frame to the last, so here we neither have any established actress playing the female lead nor much footage given to the cameos played by three major names of the industry including Gurpreet Ghuggi, Rana Ranbir and Binnu Dhillon along with Karamjit Anmol (the four big names without whom you possibly cannot make a Punjabi comedy film in the present scenario).  But surprisingly both Gurpreet and Rana get only a single individual scene with Diljit followed by another cheaply written sequence around a yoga session.
Among the girls, both Navneet Kaur Dhillion and Monica Gill are just there to add some glamour, whereas the vocally struggling Laureen Gottlieb fails to provide any extra edge to the project playing a ‘badly written’ character. Binnu Dhillon, Gul Panag and Rana Jung Bahadur remain utterly wasted, whereas the child actor tries too hard rendering his thoroughly revised lines stressing at each and every word quite forcibly.  
With only a couple of songs (included in the final edit) composed by Jatinder Shah, AMBARSARIYA also doesn’t have any of those killer tracks that could lift up the film substantially. Plus its visually unpolished look and execution doesn’t deliver a product, as it appeared to be in its appealingly designed poster and a catchy title. In fact, the film has nothing much to do with the city of Amritsar in particular except the beautiful aerial shots showcasing Harmandar Sahib (wrongly or more popularly known as The Golden Temple).
Overall, AMBARSARIYA is yet another typical Diljit Dosanjh film where he doesn’t even take a single step ahead as an actor or a performing artist. He once again does the same without offering anything fresh or novel coming out of his own comfort zone making a deliberate effort and the film fails to rise above those typical Punjabi comedies trying to sell themselves as some well written taut thrillers in disguise.
In straight words, if only witty one liner jokes, repeated taunts and cleverly rendered dialogues is all what you wish to see in a Diljit Dosanjh film, then the choice is all yours. But I am not interested in supporting the same acts again and again like some irresponsible, careless viewer ignoring the known capabilities of the star. So where you might enjoy watching AMBARSARIYA due to your own preferences, I would like to wait, till they deliver something that Punjabi Cinema can be proud of in terms of content and not in terms of some quick crores earned in their initial weekend proudly announced at all social networks.
Rating : 2 / 5
Note : Keeping the spirit of INDIA alive, I loved noticing a Punjabi film titled AMBARSARIYA beginning with the image of MA SARASWATI and the divine symbol of OM in its first few frames………..truly representing the actual spirit of our country, the real INDIA celebrating the equal existence of all……….. with HIS BLESSINGS!
Tags : Ambarsariya (Punjabi) Review by Bobby Sing, Ambarsariya Film Review by Bobby Sing, Punjabi Films Reviews by Bobby Sing at bobbytalkscinema, New Punjabi Films Reviewed by Bobby Sing, Inspired Films.
02 April 2016 / bobbysing /
leave a comment
Beginning with the film’s pre-release hype, it’s not often that you get to see a trailer which simply tells you nothing about the film or gives no clues about its actual storyline but you do get to see some impressive, meaningful sequences giving the relevant social messages by all brilliant performers. As a matter of fact, that was exactly the impact of ARDAAS’s trailer before the release and that is precisely the impact after watching the film too giving you a fair idea.
Focusing on its main character of Gurpreet Singh (a teacher, leaving his house to join a school situated in another village), the film commences with a typical religious feel generated through a devotional track and then some well-chosen quotes from the Sacred Gurbani give you a clear indication that this is surely not going to be anything usual raising the expectation levels. However, what you get served within the next couple of hours is not any specific storyline but a heartfelt amalgamation of many social subplots or short stories raising many relevant questions about our sick social system and personal choices made without taking any stand.
The film introduces you to a wide range of characters living in a particular village and tries to put in everything ranging from comedy, romance, action to emotion, religion and spirituality in its more than two hours of (a bit long) duration. Stressing on the present crumbling structure of Punjab, it tries to incorporate multiple social issues including female foeticide, farmers suicides, drug peddling, drug addiction, liquor business, improper school education, common ambition of youngsters to becomes a singer, irresponsible parenting, religion followed as a mere ritual and caste discrimination widely visible in the region in its various forms. Here though reading about these TEN meaningful issues might seem to be a great idea, but it isn’t easy to justify each one of them in a script giving them sufficient mileage in individual sequences roping in a huge supporting cast.
Thankfully ARDAAS manages to do so in a fairly appreciable manner if not in an exceptionally great style as required. And for this its writer-director Gippy surely deserves praises from the viewers as well as the industry with much love and respect. In fact his contribution to the film becomes even more important considering the point that before ARDAAS he was widely considered as a singer turned actor who could sing and perform decently on screen, especially in romantic comedies. But post ARDAAS, the man is sure to gain huge respect as a creative personality who knows much more about his art other than just singing and acting. Precisely the reason, why you hear a huge applause when he makes his screen appearance in the film (towards the end) as a turbaned Sikh. Here another person who truly deserves a big mention enhancing Gippy’s vision is his DOP Baljit Singh (a renowned director himself) who plays a major role in bringing Gippy’s dream onto the screen with impressive frames and lighting adding a lot into the film’s overall impact.
Talking about ARDAAS as a whole, there is a constant religious as well as preachy tone in its narration that gets intentionally broken with the appropriately placed comedy sequence bringing back the lighter feel. The director keeps using the flashbacks at different occasions, but since one does wish to know the real story behind its main protagonist Gurpreet, nobody feels irritated or less interested. Revealing the actual picture, ARDAAS is not any ‘masterpiece’ film presented with a highly polished vision or almost perfect execution, offering an in-depth description of several crucial issues. The film impresses majorly due to its message oriented writing and beautiful performances, that in reality lift up the narration to a much higher level demanding respect, despite having quite less to offer in terms of entertainment.
The Performances
Leading from the front, Gurpreet Singh comes up with a performance which will never allow anyone to address him as a mere comedian from here onwards in the Punjabi film industry. He makes you intensely feel for his own losses in life and delivers a career best act displaying a wide range that needs to be applauded wholeheartedly. Both BN and Sardar prove themselves as the respected veterans of Punjabi cinema through their flawless acts and Ranbir makes a big contribution in the dialogues along with playing a crucial emotional role of a postman. Ammy once again gives you an indication that here is yet another great actor in the making and so does Karamjit proving his hidden, unexplored talent using a fabulous accent. Playing the female counterparts both Mandy & Mehar underplay their given roles with elegance, Harinder, Isha and Zora play it fine as supporting cast, but the one name that truly wins your heart through his authentic dialogue delivery and innocent act is the child artist Mithu, who completely steals the show in his well-written, individual scenes so adorably.
(Spoilers Ahead)
Interestingly the best sequences of the films are the ones featuring Gurpreet and Mithu together, followed by BN’s emotional outburst remembering his son, Gurpreet’s sequence in the hospital and his sudden encounter with the spirit of his dead wife and (unborn) daughter saving him from a silly disaster. However I seriously wished this last particular scene was dealt with much more stay and emphasis to make a stronger everlasting effect on the viewers, as it was indeed a novel thought brought forward by the writer-director.
A worth publicizing hidden merit
Mentioning a hidden merit, ARDAAS has been co-produced by none other than the famous and ‘much criticized’ singer-rapper-composer Badshah making a very confident move and that too neither featuring in the film in any manner nor using his ‘professionally known’ name in the credits. Unarguably a notable example set for the entire current generation following a deceptive lifestyle.
So I would personally like to thank & congratulate Aditya Singh aka Badshah for this courageous and thoughtful move that should truly be an eye-opener for many.
The Downers
Coming to the major downers, with more than three known musical names in its key team, I honestly expected a much better soundtrack giving more emphasis to the traditional content matching the theme. But sadly there is nothing path-breaking, highly melodious or out of routine offered in its songs (apart from some appreciable lyrics). Besides in a sensible film like ARDAAS, it was painful to see many unrequired songs added as usual, including the supposedly Sufi track sung by Kanwal making a visibly forced cameo leaving no impact of any kind, whatsoever.
Tackling more than required issues and independent subplots together, the film doesn’t have an escalating pace and keeps moving on the same track with random message oriented sequences coming one after the other heading towards a predictable climax. As a result you never feel any kind of crescendo in its second half and it all ends on an open note without offering the much desired spirited peak.
In the technical department, the background score keeps trying too many things in its various sequences without maintaining any kind of consistent feel or linkage. At times it becomes too loud and melodramatic but thankfully delivers when it was required the most, in the finale. Yet ARDAAS once again made me realize that the background score mostly turns out to be a highly neglected part of a project in Punjabi Cinema, often handled too casually or inefficiently.
Anyway coming to the most avoidable part of the film, if you are making such a noble project focusing on the core issues of Punjab following a serious vision then abrupt brand promotion of already established music company & their owners in a deliberately added sequence not only looks cheap but quite illogical & irresponsible too as per my personal opinion. Hence that should have been strictly avoided and refused.
The religiously conflicting inclusions
Lastly reaching the most important part of the review, I would like to disclose some major contradictions in the film that is supposed to be an enlightening religious-spiritual project giving many valuable life-teaching lessons to the viewers believing in Gurbani and Sikhism. So here are a few honest points that might turn out to be offensive to many due to their own conflicting understanding of the sect and its various concepts.
Firstly, it can be simply ignored if this kind of mistake was made by a Hindi or any other regional language film in India, but how can a Punjabi film, made by the people of Punjab themselves, using many life teaching quotes from Gurbani, make the mistake of saying SASSRI KAAL instead of SAT SRI AKAL in its few sequences. Here even if you are ready with the much obvious justification that this is how it’s actually spoken in real life, then it even becomes more important for the makers to add a sequence teaching the right way of saying it to the audience as a part of their ‘educating’ film or mission.
But contradicting their own projected vision, it was pretty strange to see that no-body in the entire team (right till the dubbing), even thought of correcting the pronunciation of ‘Sat Sri Akal’ in the film ironically titled ARDAAS (that in reality ends with these three words only when read as a daily ritual in Gurdwaras)
Secondly, a 6-7 years old kid girl in the film is shown writing letters to the GOD calling him ‘Satnam Waheguru’ and then on the constant encouragement of Gurpreet, the postman Ranbir writes a return letter to the girl as an answer from the GOD named the same. Now as per an emotional sub-plot of a Punjabi film this seems to be very fine and touchy. But when you include this interaction in a film titled ARDAAS using the exact words ‘Satnam Waheguru’ in particular, then it all becomes highly misleading and contradictory to the faith in question i.e. Sikhism, giving an utterly wrong message to the kids watching the film taking it as something authentic.
Now why it is contradicting?
That’s because there is no concept of someone sitting up there as GOD in Sikhism. Further, neither these words ‘Satnam Waheguru’ are referred to any person listening to our prayers, nor the 10 Gurus in Sikh history along with the 11th Guru (The Divine Granth) are looked upon as GODS as per the Sikh Code of Conduct in particular. The exact word used to refer them all is GURU and not GOD (having a whole different depth in spiritual terms)
However it’s the sad irony of this faith that most of the families here teach their innocent kids with the words that Guru Nanak or Guru Gobind Singh is their GOD, also introducing them to some pictures which are not even authentically accepted and are just a mere personal depiction of an exceptionally talented painter famous worldwide.
In short there is no form of GOD to be prayed to or worshipped as per the Sikh faith and it’s all about an universal formless power guiding the existence that considers every being on earth as equals.
Anyway coming back to our topic of ‘the kid-girl’s perception’ as shown in the film, it would have been perfectly fine and appreciably conceived too, had they done it without using the religious words ‘Satnam Waheguru’. Because the moment you use these two specific words, the kids watching the film are bound to get hundreds of new vague ideas considering it the truth, beginning their own undisclosed journey on a wrong path.
Here for many this particular point might not be relevant enough to be considered. But for me it certainly is, since till the moment I was not rightly guided by my respected teachers, I too as a kid used to go to the Gurdwara with a list of things to be demanded from The Waheguru, who was supposed to be living in that clean-attractive building as his official home. And since I personally kept on dreaming with these funny illusions till long, I don’t wish the kids watching the film begin thinking the same, getting inspired from such avoidable insertions in a project titled ARDAAS (meaning prayer).
Moving ahead to the most burning or rather hurting part of the write-up, a particular well-written sequence in the film gives a highly relevant message about the caste discrimination in our society. The scene conveys that a Sikh has neither got any different caste or gotr (clan -traditional divisions in people), but believes in an equal social existence for all as taught and guided by the Gurus.
Now for once, please go through all the names mentioned in my review above and kindly notice that I have deliberately written only their first names without using the castes (surnames) in particular. This was intentionally done as that was only the core message given by the film in one of its key scenes which was evidently the best part of its impressive and widely appreciated trailer too.
However, again contradicting their own liberal vision, when I see the film’s posters, titles and credits then unfortunately I don’t find the message being followed by the makers themselves so openly and boldly. Consequently, we have GREWAL, DEO, SHARMA, VIRK, SOHI, TAKHAR, BHULLAR, VIJ, RANDHAWA & more clearly and boldly mentioned all over in the publicity material…… which are nothing but the same caste references that the film teaches you to get rid of as per the message of Sikhism.
In other words, here nobody seems to be interested in the saying ‘Practice What You Preach’. Here at one end the writer, director, actors and the entire team is proudly giving you the message of ‘No Caste Divisions in Sikh faith’, and on the other they themselves are not ready to write off their own surnames (caste representation) and keep sticking to them in the entire publicity material presenting the issue like a big JOKE.
Anyhow leaving the decision on this sick misrepresentation of the message to the intelligent readers, I would like to reveal another shameful truth about the Sikh Caste Divisions. And the truth is that though Sikhism is said to be the ‘most modern sect’ formed just a few centuries back with much liberal thought process free of all discriminations………….. the inner fact is that the word CASTE today plays a big decisive role in this sect and Sikhism has hugely wide divisions in the name of castes that are mentioned with great pride and honour in Punjab as well as in Punjabis living all over the globe, openly disobeying the clear guidance of their own Gurus.
To give you a fair idea the biggest ‘Khaayi’ (a visible ugly division) between Sikhs is of JATTS and BHAPAAS, wherein both consider each other to be some inferior beings following a sick, narrow and questionable mindset. In fact such is this wide open divide between the two, that just more than a decade back there used to be comedy audio-video albums (like Chhankata & more) in which the Jatt writers-performers openly made fun of Bhappa community projecting them as some funny creatures wearing printed clothes and Pagdis cracking silly jokes.
But why we are going back to the 90s when even one of the most famous Punjabi films that revived a dying industry in 2012 also did the same? Yes, I am talking about the cult JATT & JULIET which also has the same shameful references focusing on a father-son duo as a comic side plot added to generate some silly laughs.
For the ones who are not actually aware of this conflicting truth, there is such a deep and proud association of people of Punjab with their respective castes that you cannot even dream of writing their names without including it. To prove my point just take a look at the social networks like Facebook. See who all are praising ARDAAS appreciating it whole heartedly and then re-check their profile names. You will find the surnames mentioned in most of the cases leaving the few well-aware, not really interested in such unrequired tags.
Putting in bluntly, they all are actually praising a film that is clearly pointing towards no caste system in Sikhism and yet are using the same proudly in their profile names, redefining the word hypocrisy.  So I am really keen to see, how many of them actually get rid of these caste references from their profiles realizing this big mistake post watching ARDAAS - conveying the basic message of Sikhism with ‘No Caste Divisions”
Drawing your attention to another bizarre practice of putting and taking off the turban & beard for a screen role, many Sikhs and Sikh organisations get really upset when Bollywood actors do the same in their films wearing the fake make up of a Sikh character. However when it comes to their own singer-cum-heroes in Punjabi films they don’t really seem to have any problem when these people start growing the beard and become a turbaned Sikh in one film teaching Sikhism and then get clean shaven with shorn hair in their very next playing a romantic lead. Nobody seems to be objecting this in Punjab and Punjabi films, whereas they all consider it as an insulting issue when it comes to Bollywood and the Hindi film heroes in particular. Now if this is not hypocrisy being practiced openly then I truly don’t know what it actually is?
Incidentally this also reminds me of a highly absurd as well as funny real life instance when one of my friends was involved in the promotion of Punjabi-Hindi film called I AM SIKH released in 2011. Puneet Issar was the director of this film, also playing the key role of a Sikh police officer in it, featured prominently in all the pre-release promotion and film’s official trailers. Now when the interview was scheduled to be shot, the actors came and my friend was highly shocked to see Puneet Issar arriving in his original appearance of a bald man. Imagine he was there to promote his film I AM SIKH in which he himself had played the role of a Sikh officer, but the man was there for a promotional interview talking about his vision on Sikhism as a bald and clean shaven man without any hesitation or regret at all.
My friend called me up for suggestions and I replied, “You can do nothing my friend, just take off the standies kept in the backdrop saying I AM SIKH and shoot the interview………. Plus while shooting just keep humming one song that goes, “Golmaal Hai Bhai Sab Golmaal Hai”.
He laughed out loud and went ahead with the shoot.
The Inspirational source of ARDAAS.
Frankly I don’t think many viewers would have cracked this inspirational source of ARDAAS. But giving you an opportunity to guess, just try to think where in a famous Hindi cult classic you have seen the following story progression directed by a reputed name.
An unknown man applies for a servant’s job in a house that has many members, not having any smooth relationships with each other, caught in their own individual problems of life. The man gets the job, starts living with the family and begins teaching new precious lessons to each one of them in the film’s various segments solving their undisclosed personal issues with an amazing ease. As the time passes, the family goes through a significant positive change and the members become more cheerful and respectful to each other. They start having a dialogue and good times return to the house due to that one unknown man who was just a stranger to all only a few months back. Towards the end, the mystery man suddenly disappears and we are told that he is now gone to be the member of another troubled family who needs his specialized services.
Guessed the film? Yes it was Hrishikesh Mukherjee’s BAWARCHI featuring Rajesh Khanna as the mystery man changing the people around.
Now just visualise the man as a teacher instead of a servant, the home as a small village and the members of that one household as various families living in the village having their own problems. A teacher joins the local school, starts dealing with every key member of the village individually and tries to give them new insight of life bringing in the much needed positive change. Add a respectable religious-spiritual preachy tone to the film and incorporate all the major social issues faced by the people of Punjab as its various sub-plots played by reputed actors to the best of their ability.
That makes BAWARCHI into ARDASS to be precise.
Having said that, the mention of this inspiration angle is not to degrade the film in any manner but to make you aware that the basic structure of our Punjabi Cinema still somehow remains largely dependent upon the Hindi films only unfortunately. (However that’s a completely different tale that even BAWARCHI had its original inspiration taken from a Bengali and English film) .
Summing the long write up, Yes, Gippy has quite intelligently adapted the basic format of Hrishi Da’s film roping in some important social issues and a talented cast-ensemble giving their best to the project. As a result ARDAAS turns out to be a rare, praiseworthy, clean, message oriented film surprisingly coming from a singer turned actor revealing another facet of his creative personality to all. The film no doubt works as a whole with many well enacted, emotionally moving sequences making a solid impact, but with the message of Sikhism (imparted through extensive use of Gurbani) not being followed by the makers themselves, I am not able to rate it as any great visionary film or a trend setter.
ARDAAS surely demands respect for its concept and lessons taught, but I wish these lessons were given by setting a personal example too and not just as a pure theoretical presentation to be forgotten later.
With a hope that my honest expressions would lead to some serious introspection by all readers proudly using the castes in their names, I would love to see what Gippy announces his next as the writer-director.
Rating : 3 / 5 (The film loses its major marks because of the message being preached but not followed by the team itself)
Tags : Ardaas Movie Review By Bobby Sing, Ardaas Punjabi Film Review by Bobby Sing, Punjabi Film Reveiws at bobbytalkscinema.com, Punjabi films inspired from Hindi Cinema, Gipyy directs his first film, Punjabi films based on Gurbani, Punjabi Cinema at bobbytalkscinema.com
14 March 2016 / bobbysing /
leave a comment

AligarhThere is a long history of bold and controversial Hindi films made on the subject of homosexuality being opposed and banned even after getting a censor certificate in the past. And the ‘term’ remains a taboo or a hard to accept truth for our society till date, where even the honourable courts have displayed a rare-strange confusion by changing and then re-changing their stand on the same in the last 7 years since the much appreciated favourable verdict of 2009.

Moreover the mainstream Hindi Cinema has largely been a culprit itself for treating and misrepresenting such characters as mere silly, laughable comedians since a couple of decades, making me recall many of the recent films by renowned directors like Karan Johar or Rohit Shetty and even Rahul Rawail’s MAST QALANDER starring Dharmendra in the lead, released way back in 1991, featuring Anupam Kher as a funny, laughable clown-like gay Pinkoo wearing a weird pink coloured wig teasing the people around. To clear the doubts, before the ‘90s they were included as CHARACTERS, but post the ‘90s the writers-directors started including them as CLOWNS or mere COMEDIANS just brought in to raise some silly laughter in the theatre.

No doubt, film-makers like Onir have also delivered a few thought-provoking films too moving far ahead than any of these questionable ventures. But what director Hansal Mehta and his writer-editor Apurva Asrani offer in their much appreciated eye-opener ALIGARH, remains the most realistic and touching portrayal of the subject revealing some brutal truths of our biased, immature society like never before. In fact the film has been released with a perfect timing when the matter is again being re-considered by the courts as required.
However looking at the film from a different angle, it’s not only a brilliant visual documentation of what happened in the life of a ‘homosexual or gay’ character in particular. But it’s actually a shocking and ‘at our face’ representation of the fact that how in our present derailed society instead of focusing on our own growth & progress, we actually get more concerned or rather disturbed about the progress or respect gained by an ‘outsider’, who doesn’t really belong to the same region, religion or language quite shamefully.
Based on the true story of Dr. Shrinivas Ramchandra Siras, a professor of Marathi language in Aligarh Muslim University, the film is about the last tragic part of his life when he got suspended after getting exposed as a homosexual through a video and pictures circulated in the entire city with a purpose. The pictures/video was made by two men barging into his house at night with cameras, forcibly filming him and his male lover friend (a local rickshaw puller) in some compromising positions that later got leaked to the leading newspapers suspiciously.
The professor filed a case against his suspension order and won it too after giving logical justification for his privacy invaded by the people intentionally. But just a few days post the order, Prof. Siras was found dead in his rented house under mysterious circumstances with traces of poison found in his blood raising many unanswered question still haunting the people having lived those tense years in the university.
Yes, this incident occurred 6 years ago in 2010, but it still remains a burning relevant issue in the year 2016 too when ‘homosexuality’ has again been termed as a criminal offence by the court, a decision now being re-considered as mentioned above. Therefore, when even the courts of our country are not sure about the verdict passed earlier, I would like to talk more about the worth cherishing cinematic moments of the film instead, leaving the decision of favouring or not favouring the core-subject of homosexuality at your personal discretion.
The most appreciable beauty of ALIGARH is that the film goes much beyond its basic subject of homosexuality and also superbly explores the equally important sub-plots of middle or old age loneliness, professional jealousy felt for the ‘outsiders’, the ill-treatment faced by even old age bachelors, deliberate violation of a person’s privacy, looking at others through our own pre-set, biased notions and imposing a set social morality on to the people refusing their individual existence in the society due to many visible fears.
Its an important film, as it fearlessly reveals the things as it is without any kind of hiding or opinion forced on to the viewers asking them to take their own decision in the end. ALIGARH looks at the people as humans first without putting them into various categories differentiated on the basis of sexual preferences in particular. Powered with impressive writing, skillful direction and sensitive performances, ALIGARH doesn’t guide you towards anything, but leaves you alone with your own thinking ability to access the happenings as per your individual understanding of life.
Rightly conceived without any usual-mainstream songs, ALIGARH has a commendable background score and cinematography along with a fine editing as required (which might be its weakest part for many due to the slow pace). The film offers worth applauding moments in its both halves and among the best remain the ones where the Professor is deeply involved in his favourite old Hindi film songs sung by Lata Mangeshkar. These 2-3 minutes sequences are certainly going to be cherished the most by middle and old aged friends, personally living exactly similar moments almost daily in the evening while listening to their favourite tracks. Plus many would also smilingly agree to the dialogue wherein the Professor honestly admits that his love for books and Lata Mangeshkar was the big reason for his unsuccessful marriage too. Also the scene where the men are dancing together in an all stag-party remains one of the most subtly visualized sequences of the film besides the lunch scene between the Professor and the investigative journalist chatting in a casual manner.
Unarguably being a performance driven film, ALIGHAR entirely belongs to the immensely talented Manoj Bajpayee, who just transforms himself into the character expressing his inner feelings so truthfully with the drooping shoulders and a whispering voice-tone. It’s yet another career best performance by the gifted actor and particularly his scenes sipping whisky with Lata’s songs running in the background are sure to serve as text-book material for film & acting institutes in the coming years. Ashish Vidyarthi excels as the supportive lawyer along with other playing important small roles (like Professor’s colleague), but its Rajkumar Rao’s charming performance as the friendly journalist that simply adds a lot to the film’s overall impact, particularly in its final hour.
Having said that, I still found a few specific ‘must have’ features missing in the film, that certainly would have made the viewers feel a lot more for the main protagonist from heart post his tragic end.
Firstly, I strongly felt a lot less told in terms of humiliation faced by Professor Siras and the fight for justice in the court that could have provided an engaging pace and much more anger among the viewers thinking from the victim’s point of view.
Secondly, once again we have a typically added ‘kissing or romantic angle’ into the script that simply looked like deliberate or completely off-key in the middle of all seriously threatening events happening in the life of the lonely professor. (Here I would like to give the reference of the recent English film SPOTLIGHT, which also has a similar setting of investigative journalists and newsroom involving females, but it doesn’t even care to show them romantically involved for even a second, remaining completely focused throughout.)
Thirdly and most importantly, being a real life story of an experienced senior professor of a reputed university, I strongly wished to see the supportive or negative response of Professor’s students to the shocking findings in particular. But strangely the film doesn’t give you anything about that crucial aspect of the story at all and we don’t get to know what was Prof. Siras’s mutual relationship with his students and what was the students reaction to the acquisitions and invasion of privacy case filed as all educated, grown-up adults.
Moreover, it was also quite odd to call the university as Aligarh University repeatedly, whereas in reality the institution’s complete name happens to be Aligarh Muslim University. Now was it done knowingly or not, one cannot say, but I do recall noting the mis-quoted name at times while watching the film.
Anyway, despite having the above mentioned essential features missing in the film, ALIGARH still remains a brave, sensitive and heartbreaking expression to be seen as a must to get its right message. And the message is that its time we wake up realizing the fact that the laws we proudly quote in our court trials were actually made in 19th century when we were all slaves of the British, more than 150 years back in 1860s-70s.
Proving the irony, its being reported that the film titled ALIGARH is not being shown in the city of Aligarh itself without having any official ban imposed by the authorities. So the scenario has yet not changed in 2016, which makes it even more important to watch the film at the earliest and think about the tragedy using your own logical deduction instead of the suggested ones.
Rating : 4 / 5 (Including a big 1 for Manoj Bajpayee’s superlative performance as the Professor.)
Tags : Aligarh Movie Review by Bobby Sing, Aligarh Film Review by Bobby Sing, Aligarh on real life events, Realistic Hindi films, Hindi social films on real life happenings, New Bollywood Movies Released, New Hindi Films Reviews, New Hindi Movies Reviews, New Hindi Movies Released, New Bollywood Reviews, Bobby Talks Cinema Review, Reviews By Bobby Sing, New Hindi Films Reviews at bobbytalkscinema.com
26 February 2016 / bobbysing /
leave a comment
Reviews in All (726)

Inspired Hindi Movies
List (448)
Articles on Music,
Poetry & Life (89)
Did You Know! (85)
Few Life Inspiring Words! (21)
Nostalgia (Books on Cinema,Vintage Magazines, Scans & more) (27)
Page copy protected against web site content infringement by Copyscape
Google Analytics Alternative
The site is a collection of personal expressions of the writer to share his own views on different mediums of art, with no intention of hurting any person or organisation in particular. The site is also not responsible for any inappropriate acts practiced by the third party links added here only for information purposes.
   Visit bobbytalkscinema.com for Bollywood Movie Reviews, Inspired Cinema, Movies To See Before You Die, Amazing Bollywood Facts, Articles On Cinema, Music, Poetry & Life
Site Best View At 1024 X 768 Resolution & Above