FERRARI KI SAWAARI - A near perfect, one of the best FAMILY films of 2012 reminding you of 3 Idiots. (Review by Bobby Sing) |
15 Jun 2012 /
Comments (
16 )
Amit Joshi
Before posting my reviews about this movie I would like to remind you that I admire you alot as a person and a reviewer and most of the time (98%) your views (about life ) & reviews (about movies) are so perfect that I totally lost and wonder how a person can write with so much honesty :)
Bobby Sing
Hi Amit,
Harman
Cricket, Ferrari and the adventures of a middle class Parsi family is what this film revolves around. Ferrari ki... has a lot going on for itself on the surface. An interesting story line, a strong cast and of course the whole suspense involving whether or not Sachin Tendulkar will grace the film with his presence, is going to draw in huge crowds.
Bobby Sing
Sure it is a perfect family entertainment Harman!
Amit Joshi
Sorry writing dialogue and writing story & screenplay is entirely different thing & works quite differently for movie........for example.
The scene when sharman wants to pay his fine even when no traffic man saw him.......the traffic man says \'Ye lo rakh lo puri challan book, jab mann aaye bhar lena\' is a hilarious dialogue but the scene is totally fictitious........I bet even person like you who is too honest according to my observation will not go to traffic policeman :) instead you may say to your child \'Beta mujhse galti ho gai but one should never cross red light\'. So my problem lies with screenplay and treatment of characters which is not written & developed by Hirani. According to my Data ........Film is written by Rajesh Mapuskar, Vidhu Vinod Chopra & Neeraj Vora. Stealing Ferrari too easily, Reacting & chasing by security guards too calmly, Presenting corrupt Politician & his Son too dramatically, Boman behaving too annoyingly, Entering in meeting of selection process & threatning Chief Selector too fearlessly & Sharman showing hand to mouth in spite of a Govt Job (with only 3 members) is too much to digest. At the end everyone has their own choice and flavour. Regards, Amit Joshi
Bobby Sing
Dear Amit,
Amit Joshi
I agree but the screenplay is not written by Hirani.........and screenplay plays a vital role.
Its like Chetan had a very good story but the way Hirani and Joshi turned it into Screenplay was simply amazing......they reinvented Venkat (which was not highlighted in novel too deeply) into Chatur which was one of the strongest pillar of 3 idiot. A night @ call center is also a very good story from Chetan but the way it was adapted in movie \'Hello\' was horrible .......I think I am clear on my part. A BAD SCREENPLAY CAN EASILY RUIN A GOOD STORY. \'Avtar\' and \'Baghbaan\' both have same story but the screenplay is very different which set them very apart from each other. \'China Town\' and \'Don\' both have same story but the screenplay is very different & people like Don because of its charcterization & treatment. Regards, Amit Joshi
Bobby Sing
You are not getting the point.
Dilip Apte
Hi Bobby, I like the way you put up your case. As if you are defending an accused in Court - precise and to the point. Good job . Will be looking forward to read everything you write and grow as you write.
Bobby Sing
Thanks a lot Dilip Apte ji for your kind visit and encouraging comment.
Ajay Joshi
Hi @Amit,
Bobby Sing
Thanks Ajay for your comment and its always great to have a healthy duscussion on a movie with different viewpoints.
Vikas Saitya
Dear Bobby
Movie is simple & one time watch, but the effortless acting of very cute & talented boy wins my heart despite the presence of Sharman & Boman Irani one thing which I have noticed with Sharman in 3 Idiots (Interview Scence) & with T V crews in end In FKS, that this guy can very easily bring tears to the eyes of most of the people.( Which is really unique in todays fast paced World) Rgds Vikas
Bobby Sing
Hi Vikas,
Mustafa Kamaal Sikander
I did enjoy the movie and agree with Bobby about unnecessarily lengthy and unwanted songs which you can\'t forward because some progress may happen which unfortunately doesnt. About the Tapori politician & his son, I actually loved the movie for them than anyone else. It is so typical Bambaiya!
Bobby Sing
You are very right in your observation Mustafa regarding the red light jumping scene and thanks for sharing your views here. |
Search